Massachusetts employers are balancing competing demands. Controlling costs, recruiting and retaining employees, and adopting new technologies all require management’s attention. In that environment, employment law compliance can sometimes become a subject a company addresses only when a problem arises, rather than a consideration in the decisions that precede it.

That approach carries significant risk. Hiring a salesperson from a competitor, responding to an employee’s repeated absences, or terminating someone’s employment for misconduct may appear to be straightforward business decisions, when, in actuality, there are many underlying risks. Indeed, each of these decisions implicates several legal considerations that affect how, and when, a company should act.

Even when an employer believes it has acted appropriately, defending a legal claim brought by a current or former employee requires substantial time and expense. A discrimination charge can disrupt operations, divert managers from their responsibilities, and require the company to spend significant time revisiting matters from months, and sometimes years, earlier. Understanding common employment law issues helps employers identify concerns early and put themselves in a stronger position to defend their actions if challenged.  Below are several noteworthy considerations employers should keep in mind.

Wage Compliance Requires Careful Attention to Detail

The Massachusetts Wage Act is unforgiving. Employers that fail to pay wages when due face exposure to mandatory treble damages, reasonable attorneys’ fees, and litigation costs. Good intentions do not excuse a failure to comply with payment deadlines.

By way of example, an employee who is involuntarily terminated must receive all earned but unpaid wages, including accrued, unused vacation pay, on their date of termination. Waiting until the next regularly scheduled payday can create liability even if the company has a legitimate reason for ending the employment relationship. Managers should therefore coordinate with HR and payroll before communicating a termination decision, or, if necessary, delay termination.

Commission arrangements also deserve review. A clear written plan should explain how commissions are earned, calculated, and paid, consistent with applicable law. Ambiguity can lead to disputes over compensation that the company and employee understood differently.

Employers should likewise examine overtime classifications, timekeeping practices, and their use of independent contractors. Massachusetts generally presumes that individuals performing services are employees unless the business can satisfy a strict, three-part test. Calling someone a contractor, or issuing a Form 1099, does not resolve the classification question.

Hiring Risks Begin Before the First Day

An outdated job application can create unnecessary exposure before a candidate is interviewed. By way of example, employers should generally ask whether applicants are legally authorized to work in the United States, rather than whether they are U.S. citizens. Moreover, requests for graduation years can reveal an applicant’s age and raise questions about whether age influenced the hiring decision.

Job postings also require attention. Massachusetts employers with 25 or more employees whose primary place of work is in the Commonwealth must comply with pay transparency requirements, including disclosing a good-faith salary or hourly wage range in covered postings. Familiar forms and templates should be reviewed periodically to ensure they reflect current requirements.

Hiring from a competitor warrants additional diligence. Employers should ask about existing noncompetition, nonsolicitation, and confidentiality obligations and have relevant agreements reviewed before proceeding. Because Massachusetts still permits noncompetition agreements in limited circumstances, subject to specific requirements, a candidate’s assumption that a noncompetition agreement is unenforceable is not a sufficient basis for the company to disregard it.

Companies using noncompetition agreements should also review their own documents. Agreements subject to the Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act must meet strict requirements, including notice rules and an express statement of the employee’s right to consult counsel before signing.

Termination Decisions Need a Defensible Record

At-will employment does not eliminate the risk of discrimination, retaliation, or wrongful termination claims.  There are dozens of exceptions, and at-will employment does not stop an employee from making a claim – which is easy to do.  Employers should be able to explain the legitimate business reason for an employment termination and support that explanation with credible evidence.

That work begins well before the termination meeting. Performance evaluations should accurately reflect concerns, and managers should document misconduct and the steps taken to address it. Employers should also consider how similarly situated employees have been treated. A company that overlooks conduct by one employee but terminates another for the same conduct may have difficulty explaining the difference.

Before taking action, management should consider whether the employee has recently complained of harassment, taken protected leave, requested an accommodation, or engaged in other protected activity. These circumstances call for careful review of the decision and its supporting documentation in every case.

Leave and Attendance Issues Often Involve Overlapping Obligations

Managing attendance can become particularly difficult when employees need intermittent leave or return from an extended absence. Federal and Massachusetts leave laws may apply to the same situation while imposing different eligibility standards and requirements. Disability laws may also require consideration of an unpaid leave of absence as a reasonable accommodation even if other leave has been exhausted.

Employers should avoid treating every absence as a routine attendance matter or assuming that the exhaustion of one leave entitlement ends the analysis. Discipline during or following protected leave requires particular care. Managers need to recognize when to involve HR and counsel so that staffing concerns are addressed consistently with the employee’s rights.

Put Policies Into Practice

Certain policies are required under Massachusetts law, including a sexual harassment policy and an earned sick time policy.  Others are strongly advisable, including a code of conduct, a disciplinary policy, and a protected class harassment policy.  

Written policies are most useful when managers effectively apply them. Training should address common scenarios, including responding to harassment complaints, documenting performance concerns, and recognizing potential leave or accommodation requests. Employees should also know how to report concerns and what response to expect.

As businesses adopt artificial intelligence tools, they should examine how those tools affect hiring and other employment decisions. Existing discrimination obligations continue to apply when technology assists with a decision. Employers should understand what a tool does, review its outputs, and establish appropriate human oversight.

Periodic compliance reviews give leadership an opportunity to identify outdated practices and clarify who is responsible for addressing them. Employers cannot prevent every claim, but they can reduce avoidable mistakes and improve their ability to defend legitimate decisions. Making employment law awareness part of everyday management is essential to protecting the business as it grows and changes

Media Inquiries

Maureen C. Grenier
Chief Marketing Officer
Mirick

100 Front Street

Worcester, MA 01608-1477